Geophysics – Geospatial Modeling & Visualization / A Method Store for Advanced Survey and Modeling Technologies Thu, 22 Mar 2018 11:56:25 +0000 en-US hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.9.4 DESIGNING A FIELD STRATEGY /geophysics/designing-a-field-strategy/ Fri, 11 May 2012 20:56:52 +0000 /?p=10014 Continue reading ]]> Once it has been determined that a site is a good candidate for geophysical investigation, and appropriate geophysical methods and instruments have been selected, the next step is to plan the survey. Project goals and expectations based on previous investigations often help one develop a sampling strategy to guide the geophysical work. Large continuous areas are almost always more informative than small, discrete patches. Once it has been determined that the available instruments and selected survey strategy are detecting anomalies that appear to be consistent with archaeological features, a ground-truthing strategy should be considered to aid in directing the progress of geophysical survey. In general, it is best to begin geophysical surveys in more promising and better understood areas as a baseline before moving toward the lesser known. When a site is very large, and there are generally no clues as to where subsurface features are most likely to be located, choose a readily accessible portion of the site that is not in need of much preparation work (vegetation removal, etc). After collecting a day’s or half-day’s worth of data, hopefully the results will help you decide which way to progress. At large sites it is often best to select a few discrete locations for test surveys. If possible, keep them on the same grid system, so that they will eventually be connected if the survey is expanded.
[wptabs style=”wpui-alma” mode=”vertical”] [wptabtitle] Survey location and size[/wptabtitle] [wptabcontent]
Geophysical surveys can vary greatly in size.
• Ideally, a survey should extend a little beyond the site limits
• ensure that the area surveyed is large enough that features can be recognized based on pattern recognition
• Small features can be detected with small surveys, perhaps 15 x 15 meters or even smaller in special cases. Such small area samples may, however, make it very difficult to interpret distributional patterns.
• Much larger surveys have the benefit of revealing not only individual features and feature clusters, but entire settlements. At this “landscape” scale, the spatial layout of complete sites can be documented, and entire settlements (or, in many cases, settlement palimpsests) can be investigated. [/wptabcontent]
[wptabtitle] Setting up grid[/wptabtitle] [wptabcontent]

The importance of accurately setting up a grid cannot be stressed enough. If the grid has internal error, or if it cannot be accurately located on the ground in relation to a base map, then the value of the geophysical survey is greatly diminished. Copious notes should also be taken so that the grid can be relocated in the future. (The term “grid” can be confusing sometimes because it is used in many different ways. To avoid confusion we use the word “grid” here in the traditional sense, and describe the individual geophysical survey units in a grid as “tiles.”)
There are a variety of ways to set up a grid for geophysical survey. For small areas, tape measures can be used without the help of a transit or similar device. Right-angles for tile corners can be closely approximated using the Pythagorean Theorem. This method works well for small grids, but as the size of the grid increases, the error gets progressively worse. When relocating a point on the ground to investigate an anomaly, one should tape distances from the corner of that particular tile where survey began. In order to correct error later it is important to record the GPS locations of the tile corners. A dumpy level or an optical square can be used to sight in straight lines and right angles, but taped distances will still be erroneous the farther the grid is extended from the starting point. A much more accurate and precise way to set up a grid is to use a total station or survey-grade GPS.
The orientation of a grid with respect to architectural or other linear features is extremely important. Several problems can occur if data are collected along lines that are parallel to walls or other linear features (e.g., ditches, fences, roads).
• a narrow linear feature could be entirely missed if it falls between collection traverses
• Lines can be easily mistaken for instrument malfunction or interference from outside sources
• anomalies that parallel collection lines will often be removed by a de-striping filter
It is therefore important to choose a grid orientation that is at least 20 degrees offset from the dominant trend in architecture. Where possible it is beneficial to set up the grid close to 45 degrees offset from the architecture (or linear features of interest). [/wptabcontent]

[wptabtitle] Tile Size[/wptabtitle] [wptabcontent]

Tile size is often a difficult decision to make, and there are many factors to consider. Using very small tiles (e.g., 10 x 10 m) over a large area will result in a large number of data files. If tiles are too large (40 x 40 or larger), it will take too long to survey each one and the surveyor will probably need to take breaks before a tile is complete. Large tiles have several problems
• most instruments drift over time, small tiles allow for re-calibration
• when survey is resumed after a break, the readings of the new line will not match well with the line of data collected before the break, so an edge-discontinuity is created
• Data collection has to stop at the end of the day or when batteries are drained, so it is best to use a tile size that is both large enough to keep the number of data files manageable, while also small enough that a tile can be finished in under an hour.
• Small tiles are better in oddly shaped or confined spaces
• Managing “walking ropes” or tape measures difficult over large distances
Small tiles are also easier when there are other things going on during the survey that need periodic attention, such as talking to the public, helping with other parts of the field effort, or attending to a GPS unit or battery charger.
Another factor to consider with tile size is uniformity. When using multiple methods at one site it is best to pick one tile size for all instruments. This way, the grid can be set up with markers at every tile corner, and a single set of pre-cut survey ropes can be used for all instruments. A common method in North America is to lay out a grid with markers every 20 meters. The most commonly used software packages for magnetometry and resistivity (Geoplot and ArchaeoSurveyor) also follow this convention and require that all tiles be the same size in order to be displayed and processed together, which simplifies programming. Note that Archaeomapper is designed to process edge discontinuities that occur between and within tile boundaries with ease, and allows tiles of different sizes and data densities in the same survey. We suggest that ropes be laid down along survey lines at all odd meters (1, 3, 5, and so on up to 19 m). Using this technique, there are no locations in the tile that are more than 1 m away from a survey rope, so distances along each transect can be easily estimated for rapid survey.

Ground penetrating radar survey is distinctly different from the other methods. We suggest that larger tiles be used to minimize processing time using 40 x 40-m tiles.
• The edges line up with the typical 20 x 20 m tile boundaries of other surveys, but there are only one quarter as many tiles to process.
• at half-meter line spacing it is likely that a tile can be surveyed in 3-4 hours.
• Two 50-meter measuring tapes are used for baselines and a third one as a “walking tape,” which is moved along as lines are surveyed.
• Keep in mind, however, that this method requires at least two and preferably three people, and does not leave much time for breaks during the long surveys.
With EMI, larger tiles are not recommended because, unlike GPR, EMI data (both conductivity and MS) are prone to drift. With a sensor that drifts it is better to tune it frequently, such as before each 20 x 20 m tile. [/wptabcontent]
[wptabtitle] Data Density[/wptabtitle] [wptabcontent]

The ability to detect small or low contrast features depends heavily on the data (or sampling) density of the geophysical survey. The limiting factor for feature detection and image resolution is therefore the distance between lines. The traditional sampling density for most methods is reported to be 1-2 samples per m². We suggest that the traverse interval should be geared to the nature of the site and expected features. Data density should be high enough such that the smallest feature to be detected is recorded at least twice and preferably more for reliable detection. This means that if the target feature is 1 m in diameter the data density should be at least .5 x .5 m so that it is likely to be recorded more than once and thus distinguishable from a data spike.
Unfortunately, the advantages of high data density surveys are accompanied by higher costs. A balance between meeting the survey goals and costs should be found. This sometimes means surveying a smaller area with higher data density rather than a large area at a lower density, or vice versa. Some software packages (including ArchaeoMapper) allow one to remove every other line of data in order to assess the impact on anomaly detection. Where this capability exists, it is wise to begin with a higher density survey, and reduce this if anomalies consistent with features are detected using the lower density.[/wptabcontent]

[wptabtitle] Data Density 2[/wptabtitle] [wptabcontent]The term data density can sometimes be confused with image resolution. Data density refers to the number of data values per m² collected in the field. During processing, interpolation procedures are used to cosmetically improve an image by reducing pixel size. Such interpolation is, however, no substitute for an increase in true data density, and it will not aid in the detection of small or low contrast features.
Many instruments are designed to record measurements at regular intervals along each transect. Most magnetometers and EMI instruments emit an audible beep at regular intervals, such as every second, in order to guide the surveyor. The surveyor can then choose how many measurements will be taken between each beep, or can alter the time interval between beeps. This requires that the surveyor is able to proceed at a fairly constant pace. If there are many obstacles, readings can be taken manually by pushing a button, although this is difficult in situations where 8 readings per meter must be recorded. Alternatively, some instruments allow the surveyor to keep track of distance continuously by recording a fiducial-mark every meter or so. The meter marks are then used to interpolate, or “rubbersheet”, between markers. This is often done with GPR, but an easier way to record GPR data is to use a survey wheel. The wheel attaches to the antenna and works as an odometer, taking an equal number of measurements per meter.[/wptabcontent]
[wptabtitle] Ground Surface Preparation[/wptabtitle] [wptabcontent]

While it is ideal for a site to be blanketed in short, smooth grass, most sites are covered in some combination of tall grass, cacti, bushes, and trees. The ideal solution is to remove any vegetation that impedes the movement of geophysical equipment. The method of vegetation removal should be carefully considered. A lawn mower can be used to clear grass, but care should be taken not to do this on days when the ground is soft because shallow tire tracks can be detected by most geophysical methods. If bushes are removed, they should be chopped down to ground level but the root system left in place rather than removed because this would create an anomaly on its own.
As discussed previously, metal debris on and near the surface creates a problem for magnetometry survey, and to some extent conductivity. If metal debris is extensive, then magnetometry survey is not worthwhile until the debris is removed. This adds considerable time and cost to the project, because removing metal entails locating each piece with a metal detector and then usually digging for it with a trowel. This kind of impact might not be acceptable at some (unplowed, cemetery, battlefield) sites. It is a worthwhile effort, however, when magnetometry is the best method for meeting the survey goals. [/wptabcontent]
[wptabtitle] Survey Supplies[/wptabtitle] [wptabcontent] A variety of field supplies are either required or very helpful for a geophysical survey, particularly for large surveys using multiple instruments. Here we provide a list of basic supplies needed for a survey, but it is not exhaustive.

Tile corner markers. Plastic sections of ½-inch diameter pvc pipe works well to mark tile corners. They can usually be pounded in easily and are readily visible. They can be written on with permanent marker to show the grid coordinates and tile number, or marked with flagging tape that bears this information.

Plastic or wooden stakes. These are best for pinning survey ropes across grid tiles, and can also be used as tile corner markers. Compared to wooden stakes, plastic stakes or ten pegs are easier to work with, last much longer, and are often cheaper.

Flagging tape. This is useful to mark stakes or other tile markers, and other locations.

Plastic Pin flags. Pin flags are useful for marking tile corners, tuning stations, and monitoring stations. Plastic is much preferred over metal for the sake of magnetometry. We advocate that archaeologists never use metal pin flags at sites that may someday be the subject of geophysical survey.

Rubber mallet. A mallet or hammer makes pounding in stakes easier, and one made of rubber is less likely to damage them. Rubber mallets often include some metal, however, so they should be tested before being left within range of a magnetometer.

Tape Measures. Tape measures are needed when laying out a grid unless a total station is available. They can also be used to stretch out along baselines to set up tiles for survey. It is handy to have three tape measures, 30-50 m long each. It is also nice to have one 100-m tape that you can stretch along a series of tiles, or use to measure the hypotenuse when setting-in tiles. If large GPR tiles are being used, tape measures are best for guiding the survey.

Chaining pins. These can be used to secure one end of a tape, allowing one individual to establish a series of tiles. Make sure to remove them prior to magnetometry or EMI surveys!

Survey ropes. Survey ropes are precut sections of rope with meter markers that are highly visible. They are used to lay out a tile for survey. If the typical 20 m tiles are used, then these ropes should be made long enough to lay across the entire 20 m, with some slack at the ends so a loop can be tied. Meter marks can be made visible with brightly colored spray paint, duct tape, or electrical tape. It is also helpful to use different colors to mark increments, such as every five meters, so that distances along the rope can be easily determined. Fiberglass survey tapes, which do not stretch, are available in large rolls from many survey suppliers.

Notebook and pencils. Obviously there is much information to record in the field. Books with grid lines are helpful for sketching the site grid.

Pre-made Forms. For large surveys especially, it is useful to develop a standard form that can be used to record information about each tile. It saves time if the standard-sized tile is already drawn on the form that can be used to sketch in anything on the surface that will affect the interpretation of the data, such as vegetation patterns and the locations of obstacles. If doing resistivity, it is also useful to record the measurements from each tile coner, so that when survey is continued the remote probes can be repositioned to make adjacent tiles match.

Compass. This is especially important for magnetometry, because tuning and set up require that magnetic north be located rather accurately.

Tunings Stands. Fluxgate magnetometers can be tuned standing on the ground as instruction manuals advise, but it is much better to be elevated above the ground. A plastic or some other non-metal stool can be used for this. It is particularly important for dual sensors, because if they are close to the ground they could each find a different zero, resulting in a strong striping pattern in the data. EM instruments, particularly the EM38, also should be elevated high above the ground for tuning. While the instrument can be held this way while standing, it is very tiring and probably not as accurate because it is not held perfectly steady and at the right angle. A collapsible platform can be made out of pvc pipe or some other non-metal material. Use of a bubble level to ensure that the instrument is being held vertically can reduce the time needed to properly tune a Geoscan gradiometer.

Total Station or some other mapping implement. A total station is best, but an optical transit, dumpy level or optical square can be used for small grids.

GPS unit. The geophysical grid should be mapped into real world coordinates if possible, for record keeping and integration with other data in GIS.

Portable Computer. This is necessary to download data, as most instruments do not hold more than a day’s worth. It is also important to take a look at data each day to check for errors and see how the methods are working.

Software. The download and processing software for each instrument should be loaded onto the portable computer, but it is also a good idea to have a back-up copy on disk in case the computer fails.

Means to establish a permanent datum. The geophysical data are not worth very much if the grid cannot be relocated on the ground surface in the future. Unless the real-world coordinates of the grid are known (and can be precisely relocated with a GPS), the geophysical grid should be marked with a datum that will last at least long enough to be more accurately documented. A post-hole digger or shovel should be used to dig a hole and fill with cement, with rebar or pvc pipe embedded for visibility. Sometimes the datum should be low to the ground so it will not be removed, damaged, or pose a danger to passing vehicles. Use of rebar is debatable. It is more durable than PVC, and can be relocated with a metal detector, but will cause a large anomaly in future magnetometer surveys. If using rebar, consider temporarily removing it prior to any future magnetometry surveys.
[/wptabcontent] [/wptabs]

]]>
Using the Bartington Grad 601 with Two Sensors in the Field /scanning/using-the-bartington-grad-601-with-two-sensors-in-the-field/ Mon, 16 May 2011 13:03:36 +0000 /?p=2563 Continue reading ]]> [wptabs mode=”vertical”] [wptabtitle] Using the Bartington Grad 601 with Two Sensors in the Field[/wptabtitle] [wptabcontent]Using the Bartington Grad 601 with Two Sensors in the Field
Jason T. Herrmann
Center for Advanced Spatial Technologies
University of Arkansas
written for the geophysical field school at Tell el-Amarna, January, 2011

The following is a simplified version of the concepts and steps described in the Bartington Grad601-2 manual colored with some of the practices and preferences of the author. These instructions assume that you have a survey area selected and gridded for survey. Surveys are most often conducted by methodically covering 20 x 20 meter squares set in a grid. The Grad601-2 has two gradiometers mounted on a trapeze that is one meter long, but archaeological surveys are often conducted at 50cm resolution. To achieve this density of readings, the surveyor will need to plot a survey strategy that has overlapping coverage under the span of the trapeze. For more detail on this and other aspects of instrument or survey methods, see the Bartington Grad601-2 survey manual.


[/wptabcontent]

[wptabtitle] Prepare for Survey [/wptabtitle] [wptabcontent]
Be Metal Free
It is important that the user be absolutely metal free for the survey. After you let the instrument warm up, you can check to see if your survey wear is metal free by running the Grad 601-2 in SCAN mode and moving your body around the sensors paying particular attention to your shoes, waistline, wrists and headgear. If there is a change in the readings outside of normal drift (±0.2 nT), then you should identify the magnetic item and remove it from your person before survey.[/wptabcontent]

[wptabtitle] Let the Instrument Warm Up[/wptabtitle] [wptabcontent]
Letting the instrument warm up as you set the survey grid will help you to avoid any drift in readings as you survey. Assemble and turn on the gradiometer as soon as you get into the field.[/wptabcontent]

[wptabtitle] Assemble the Gradiometer[/wptabtitle] [wptabcontent]
If you are using the CAST gradiometer, be aware that it has been found that the sensor with the serial number 157 prefers to be on the left and 168 works better on the right. This will make tuning in the field go much more quickly. Slide the gradiometer rods into the clamps on the trapeze and firmly tighten the screws to lock the gradiometers into place. Attach the gradiometers to the data logger by screwing the connector wires into the gradiometers. Don the harness and adjust the straps so that the harness is comfortable. There is a strap to extend the belt on the harness if you need it. Use the plastic clips on the harness to hang the trapeze from the harness using the rubber rings. Adjust the straps on the harness to get the sensors as close to the ground as possible but still high enough to walk smoothly and comfortably. Having the sensors hang 20cm above the ground surface is ideal.

Press the ON/OFF button to activate the Grad601-2.[/wptabcontent]
[wptabtitle] Conducting Survey : Setting Parameters[/wptabtitle] [wptabcontent]

Use the arrow keys to navigate the menu in the data logger and press STEP to cycle through the options for each menu item. The individual parameters and available settings are explained below with the standard selection in bold:

Pace: the walking pace of the operator. Most surveys are between 0.7 and 1.0 secs. Since the data you record is an average of almost continuous variation sensed by the instrument during data collection, the slower you walk, the smoother your data will be.
Grid Size: select the size of grid – 10 x 10, 20 x 20, 30 x 30 or 40 x 40m.
Start: select the starting direction of the grid, N, NE, E, SE, S, SW, W or NW. This depends on your grid orientation. If your grid is oriented north and you are starting in the southwest corner then you may want to select N or NW as your starting direction. Pattern: select the traverse pattern to be followed – Parallel or ZIGZAG.
Lines/m: select the required number of data lines per meter – 1, 2 or 4. Two (2) lines per meter is standard (50cm transect spacing).
Samples/m: select the number of samples per meter along each line – 1, 2, 4 or 8. 8 samples per meter is the standard setting, but is not available for grids of 40 x 40m.
Range: select the full scale range of 100nT (resolution 0.03nT) or 1000nT (resolution 0.1nT).
Audio: select the audio output for scanning and survey operations – off or ON.
Volume: select volume – HIGH or low.
Threshold: select the deviation in nT at which the alarm is required to operate during a scan operation – increments in units, tens and hundreds and thousands of nT. When the field deviates by the level selected, the ALARM message will be shown in the display for the appropriate sensor, and the audio output rate will start to increase. The audio tone varies from the value set to about ten times this value. This depends on the background values at your survey site. 100nT is generally a safe threshold.
Sensors: select the number of sensors to be used – 1 or 2
Reject: select the frequency of 50 or 60Hz to reduce noise in the data.[/wptabcontent]
[wptabtitle] Tuning the Instrument [/wptabtitle] [wptabcontent]

What you will need:

  1. Grad 601-2
  2. Compass
  3. Stakes or markers

One of the many wonderful things about the Bartington Grad 601-2 is how easy it is to tune.

  1. Before you begin to tune the instrument, set the gradiometer to SCAN and see if you can find a magnetically ‘quiet’ spot to tune.
  2. Use a compass to lay out a place where you can tune the instrument. You will need to accurately identify the cardinal directions, so mark the four cardinal directions with nonmagnetic materials in the magnetically quiet spot that you have identified.
  3. Now you are ready to tune the instrument. Navigate to ADJUST GRADIOMETER and follow the simple directions to zero the instrument. To get the best adjustment, try to elevate the magnetometer as high as possible above the ground. If you don’t have a nonmagnetic stool or ladder, hold the instrument high over your head. Try your best to be consistent in holding the instrument in the same space throughout the tuning process. If the instrument is exceptionally out of tune, the Grad 601-2 may ask you to repeat the process. Once you have finished tuning, run SCAN and look at the measurements coming in to the gradiometers while facing north in the spot where you have tuned. They should both be close to 0.0 nT.
  4. With the Grad 601-2 strapped to the harness, go to the start point of your survey and stand as if you are ready to begin survey. Take note of the readings at this point while the Grad 601-2 is scanning. After several grid squares, come back to this point and see if you get similar readings. If they are different by more than 0.5nT, you will want to adjust the gradiometer again before continuing.

[/wptabcontent]

[wptabtitle] Collecting Data [/wptabtitle] [wptabcontent]

Remember, this set of instructions assumes that you have already set up your survey grid and that you are using two sensors mounted one meter apart.

  1. Stand at the “lower left” corner of your survey square where the end of your first transect would be the ‘top’ of the survey square. Face the survey direction. If your transects are oriented to the north, this would be the southwest corner. Be sure to start all surveys in the same corner.
  2. If you are surveying with two sensors and plan a map that has transects that are spaced at 50cm, you will need to pass over the grid so that the survey transects shuffle together during survey. On your first transect, you would walk a line that is 75cm from the corner. Your return transect would be 1.25m from the corner.
  3. Press ENTER or the green button on the trapeze when you begin a line. If you have set the parameters correctly and walked at the correct pace the Grad601-2 will beep every time you pass over a meter mark on your survey rope and beep twice at the end of the transect.
  4. Press ESC or the red button on the trapeze to stop survey during a traverse.
  5. If you have made a mistake, you can delete the current line (or if completed, the last line) by navigating to BACK ONE TRAV and pressing ENTER. You will delete another line every time you press ENTER.
  6. Continue the survey until the square is finished. Stopping during survey could introduce some unwelcome interference into your data.

[/wptabcontent]

[wptabtitle] Take a Break[/wptabtitle] [wptabcontent]
It is okay to leave the Grad 601-2 on if you are going to take a short break. When not surveying, please try to leave the instrument in the shade. If there is no shade cover, at least protect the computer/data logger with a cloth to protect it from the sun.

Turn the Grad 601-2 off if you are taking a longer break, say for second breakfast or lunch. You will need to re-adjust the instrument when you begin survey again.[/wptabcontent]
[wptabtitle] Downloading Data [/wptabtitle] [wptabcontent]

The Bartington Grad 601-2 will organize data from a zig-zag survey with two sensors as if it were collected with one sensor with a unidirectional survey prior to downloading, therefore no additional organization of readings is required after downloading. This applies for all three downloading methods.

What you will need:

  1. Bartington data logger
  2. Bartington Grad601 software
  3. Download cable (and driver if necessary)
  4. Computer

[/wptabcontent]
[wptabtitle] Download Steps [/wptabtitle] [wptabcontent]

  1. Make sure you have the Bartington Gradiometer download utility installed on your computer. This small program can be downloaded from Bartington Instruments’ website or installed from a disk that should be packed with the gradiometer.
  2. Connect the computer to the Grad 601-2 via the serial port in the back of the Gradiometer. Use a serial to USB connector if your computer does not have a serial port (as most new laptops do not). If you are using a serial to USB cable, be sure to install the proper driver for the cable before attempting to download.
  3. Activate the Bartington download utility.
  4. Choose OUTPUT DATA from the menu on the Grad 601-2 data logger. When you do, the screen should read WAITING FOR PC.
  5. Identify the correct COM port for download. If you just installed a driver for a cable, you were probably notified which port the driver was applied to.
  6. Choose the data format for download. XYZ format is recommended, as it is the most versatile and can be recognized by most programs.
  7. Hit START when you are ready to download and watch the bytes pour in!
  8. The download software will ask you to save the data when you are finished. Generally, you will want to Save All files, and save them with a unique identifier. One recommended file naming strategy is to save data with a name that includes the date they were collected and the sequential number of the grid square collected. For example, data from the first three grid squares collected on January 13 would be saved as 01-13-01, 0113-02 and 01-13-03. To save all the grids from January 13 in this scheme, enter “01-13-“ in the windows explorer window when prompted to choose a name for the files. The grid number will automatically be added after the dash.
  9. You will get two files for each grid square, a .dat file that will hold the data and a .hdr file that has the parameters for each grid square.

[/wptabcontent]
[wptabtitle] Charging and Care [/wptabtitle] [wptabcontent]

The Grad 601-2 holds a charge that will serve many days of survey. When you need to charge the battery, slide the charge port cover over and attach the AC charger. This charger has interchangeable plugs for use outside of the United States.[/wptabcontent] [/wptabs]

]]>